Induction Lamp vs Other light source

Induction VS LED Induction VS HID
Induction VS Fluorescent lamps Lumen maintenance of Induction VS Other light sources

 

Induction VS LED

COMPARISON Induction LAMPS LED
Market Potential Size Induction lamps can replace most of conventional light sources in functional lighting fields, so its potential market size will be huge. In addition, the incandescent lamp will be phased out in many countries in the very near future, so there will be a big space for energysaving light sources development. Although LED has many years of history, it only can be used for the traffic signal, vehicle rear lights, LCD panel back-lighting, display lighting because of lower lumen efficacy, lower wattage, and less lighting fixtures accommodated. It will take a lot of time to develop large wattage model of LED in order to apply LED in the functional lighting fields
Economy With the development of large-scale production, Induction lamps’ cost will be reduced much The higher cost of LED will be kept for many years, so its wide application will be limited.
Energy-saving Induction lamps can save up to 50% of energy consumption than LED, because Induction lamps’ efficacy is 30% higher than LED and lumen depreciation rate is lower much than LED. LED will consume much more energy than Induction lamps because of its lower efficacy, higher lumen depreciation rate.
Application Can be used in the industrial, commercial, roads, tunnels, bridges, gardens and parks, agricultural, advertising lighting. Can be used in the traffic signal, vehicle rear lights, LCD panel back-lighting, display lighting.
Functional Lighting Application Induction Lamps can be widely applied for diversified functional lighting application. It is commercialized quickly around the world. Because of lots of barriers for LED’s R&D, it will take 5~10 years for LED to be applied widely in the functional lighting application.
Technical Specification 1. Wattage:15W~400W
2. Efficacy:>80 lm/W
3. CRI:>80 Ra
4. CCT:2100K~6500K, All range.
5. Lumen depreciation:5%@2000hrs
6. Lifetime:>100,000 hrs
7. Heat output:much lower
8. Fixture accommodated easily
9. Linear light source:no glaring and
flickering, better light quality
1. Wattage:0.5~50W per each. Big wattage output
needs hundreds of LEDs。
2. Efficacy :<60 lm/W (white LED)
3. CRI:>80 Ra
4. CCT:narrow range(white LED)
5. Lumen depreciation :>50%@2000hrs
6. Lifetime:<50,000hrs
7. Heat output:much higher
8. Fixture accommodated hardly because of heatreleasing
design and reflector design
9. Spot light source:glaring concern

 

Induction VS HID

Comparison Item Induction lamps MHL HPS HPM
Warranty 5 yrs 1 yrs None None
Life Span Compact: 60,000 hrs
Separate: 100,000 hrs
6,000~20,000 hrs (Short lifetime because electrode works under high temperature up to 1200 ℃) 24,000 hrs (Short lifetime because electrode works under high temperature up to 1200 ℃) 3,000~6,000 hrs (Short lifetime because electrode works under high temperature up to 1200 ℃)
Energy Saving Efficiency Excellent Lower Lower Lower
Lumen Efficacy Photopic Efficacy: 150 Plm/W
(Plm: Pupil Lumen)
Traditional Efficacy: 80 Lm/W
Photopic Efficacy: 110 Plm/W
(Plm: Pupil Lumen)
Traditional Efficacy: 75 Lm/W
Photopic Efficacy: 90 Plm/W
(Plm: Pupil Lumen)
Traditional Efficacy: 120 Lm/W
Photopic Efficacy: 43 Plm/W
(Plm: Pupil Lumen)
Traditional Efficacy: 50 Lm/W
Lumen Depreciation Rate (%) 5% @2000 hrs 40% @2000hrs 30% @2000hrs 45% @2000 hrs
Lamp Temperature Lower, <80℃. Reduce A/C cost Higher, >300 ℃. Increase A/C cost Higher, >350 ℃. Increase A/C cost Higher, >300 ℃. Increase A/C cost
CRI >80 (Ra) 65~90 (Ra) 60 (Ra) Lower, 45 (Ra)
Restrike Instantly Need up to 10~15 minutes Need up to 10~15 minutes  
Application Can be used for all kinds of general lighting      
Flicker None Much Much Need up to 10~15 minutes
Glare None Much Much Need up to 10~15 minutes
Environment Friendly No mercury. No any waste lamps in 10 years. Much concerns of lots of waste lamps Much concerns of lots of waste lamps Much concerns of many waste lamps/Mercury

 

Induction VS Fluorescent lamps

Comparison Item Induction lamps Compact Fluorescent Lamps Linear Fluorescent Lamps
Warranty 5 yrs None None
Life Span Compact: 60,000 hrs
Separate: 100,000 hrs
8,000~10,000 hrs 8,000~12,000 hrs
Energy Saving Efficiency Excellent Good Worse
Lumen Efficacy Photopic Efficacy: 150 Plm/W
(Plm: Pupil Lumen)
Traditional Efficacy: 80 Lm/W
Photopic Efficacy: 85 Plm/W
Traditional Efficacy: 50 Lm/W
Photopic Efficacy: 69 Plm/W
Traditional Efficacy: 70 Lm/W
Lumen Depreciation Rate (%) 5% @2000 hrs 30% @2000 hrs 25% @2000 hrs
Application Can be used for all kinds of general lighting Residential (small wattage) / Industrial (large wattage) Only commercial because of small wattage
Flicker None Much Much
Glare None Much Much
Environment Friendly No mercury. No any waste lamps in 10 years. Much concerns of mercury and lots of waste lamps Much concerns of mercury and lots of waste lamps

 

Lumen maintenance of Induction VS Other light sources

Lumen maintenance of  Inducton VS Other light sources

 

 

 

EMS Energy Maintenance Service.Co.Ltd.

54/7 Moo.1, Chalong, Muang, Phuket 83130 THAILAND l Tel: (+66)7 636 7146 Fax: (+66)7 636 7147

Copyright © 2009. Energy Co., Ltd. All Right Reserved.Website: www.energy.co.th Email: info@energy.co.th

Software development and Web design by Blue D.Zine